At One NY High School, Failing Is Passing

Washington Irving High School's administrators have approved new grading policies that give failing kids credits toward graduation, writes Susan Edelman at the New York Post.

The school was recently granted $6 million in extra funds to undergo a transformation and help overturn its poor performance.

The policies are spelled out in documents obtained by The Post, including the 2011-12 staff handbook and minutes of a meeting last October between Principal Bernardo Ascona and assistant principals who make up the school's Panel for Academic Success, writes Edelman.

Under these rules:

Students who get failing scores of 50 to 55 in class will "automatically" get 15 points for a passing 65 to 70 grade if they pass a Regents exam. Kids who score a minimum 65 on the Regents "should receive a passing grade" in the class. Interestingly, the same practice forced a Bronx principal to resign.

A final grade of 60 to 64 "will be changed automatically" to a passing 65.

Students who fail a class "will be assigned … a work product not to exceed five pages" or "alternative project."

David Bloomfield, an education professor at Brooklyn College, said such policies make a mockery of "real learning and subject mastery."

"This is simply a phony process for getting kids undeserved credits," he said.

"The message is loud and clear: Don't worry if you don't attend school — we'll just give you an easy way to make up the credit," a staffer said. "What does that say to the kids who actually do the class work, tests, projects and homework?"

The city Department of Education said officials will review the school's grading practices and is auditing 60 unnamed schools to look for lax scoring and credit-granting.

Struggling schools like Washington Irving are under the gun to boost their numbers or else face closure, writes Edelman.

At Lehman High School in The Bronx, Principal Janet Saraceno resigned in August after a probe found she improperly changed grades and gave credits to some 30 students who had failed their classes but barely passed Regents exams, as reported at NY 1.

Saraceno broke a Department of Education rule that a Regents score can make up no more than 33 percent of a final class grade, it was found. The Department of Education gave Saraceno a new job, with the same salary, as an "achievement coach", writes Edelman.

Washington Irving is one of 12 city schools chosen to each get federal grants of up to $2 million a year for three years to "transform."

The school barely escaped the Department's ax by claiming a dramatic boost in its four-year graduation rate. It reported a 55 percent rate last year — still below the citywide average of 63 percent but up from a dismal 38.3 percent the year before.

However, records show just 5 percent of last year's seniors were considered "college or career ready" based on their Regents exams.

Privacy Policy Advertising Disclosure EducationNews © 2019