Educators are finding that kids aren’t coming to school prepared to learn because they are... Read More
Michelle Bachmann: Do We Need a US Department of Education?
As the 2012 Election season heats up, Michelle Bachmann raises an old question during Republican primary debates: What about the US Department of Education?
Was Representative Michelle Bachmann correct when she said that, constitutionally, the federal government has no role in education in the United States? During a town hall in South Carolina, Bachmann, one of the leading contenders for the Republican Presidential nomination, answered a question posed to her by Senator Jim DeMint by pledging to get rid of the Department of Education if she is elected:
“Because the Constitution does not specifically enumerate nor does it give to the federal government the role and duty to superintend over education that historically has been held by the parents and by local communities and by state governments,” she said, responding to a question by DeMint, a popular figure among the tea party movement.
Tina Korbe, writing for HotAir.com, backs Bachmann’s reading of the Constitution. Although the DoE is not unconstitutional, it is not specifically listed as one of the duties that the federal government must undertake. But the true question, as Korbe points out, is would it hurt or help American kids if the responsibility of their education were to devolve to the local and state governments. The answer to the question is not straight-forward.
Naturally, questions of right and equity enter in. It is, after all, commonly accepted that children have the right to an equal education (although even that could be debated). But as regards efficacy, it’s pretty clear flexibility and freedom to address the needs of individual children enhances education.
As the 2012 election season is ramping up, the quality of education in the country is once again the focus of great debate. The Washington Times lists education as one of the central issues for this election.
Jack Jennings, president and CEO of the Center of Education Policy thinks that Republicans will be using the issue to attack President Obama this time around, in a similar way that they used Administration’s health care policy in 2010:
Education “is traditionally more of an issue that is discussed, but it doesn’t reach the top tier. This time, it’s possible that it can, because there seems to be more of a clear difference between the parties,” he said.
Shortly after announcing his candidacy for President, Texas Governor Rick Perry called for abolishing the Department of Education, prompting the current Secretary Arne Duncan to say that he “feels bad for the children of Texas.”
Although elimination of the DoE was part of the Republican platform in the 1990s, after President George W. Bush was elected, one his first legislative priorities was passing the No Child Left Behind law, which greatly expanded the Department’s role in American education. This time around, several candidates are calling for a return to the previous policy.
Jennings is unsure about the effectiveness of this strategy, however.
The “business” wing of the party, he said, supports efforts to better educate the nation’s students to compete in the global economy. The Chamber of Commerce, for example, earlier this year released a blueprint for reforming the federal government’s role in education, not eliminating it.
by John Jensen, PhD The debate over high-stakes testing pits the need for assessing student... Read More
Teachers and parents spoke out at the Denver Public Schools board meeting about the... Read More
Researchers are expecting a surge in the number of students educated at home by their parents over... Read More
Plan your career as an educator using our free online datacase of useful information.
- Select a Subject
- Advertising Schools
- MBA Schools
- Sports Management Schools
- Visual Communications Schools
- Select a State Subject
- Advertising Schools in Maryland
- MBA Schools in Virginia
- Sports Management Schools in California
- Visual Communications Schools in Wisconsin
- Select a City Subject
- Advertising Schools in North East
- Advertising Schools in Towson
- MBA Schools in Arlington
- MBA Schools in Charlottesville
- MBA Schools in Chesapeake
- MBA Schools in Fredericksburg
- MBA Schools in Lexington
- MBA Schools in Norfolk
- MBA Schools in Radford
- MBA Schools in Richmond
- MBA Schools in Staunton
- MBA Schools in Williamsburg
- Sports Management Schools in Cypress
- Sports Management Schools in Fresno
- Sports Management Schools in Fullerton
- Sports Management Schools in Hayward
- Sports Management Schools in Irvine
- Sports Management Schools in Moraga
- Sports Management Schools in Oakland
- Sports Management Schools in Pleasant Hill
- Sports Management Schools in Riverside
- Sports Management Schools in San Francisco
- Sports Management Schools in Stockton
- Visual Communications Schools in Beloit
- Visual Communications Schools in Fond du Lac
- Visual Communications Schools in Green Bay
- Visual Communications Schools in La Crosse
- Visual Communications Schools in Madison
- Visual Communications Schools in Mequon
- Visual Communications Schools in Milwaukee
- Visual Communications Schools in Plymouth
- Visual Communications Schools in Stevens Point