ADHD/Ritalin: Teachers, Psychiatrists, Social Workers, Judges, Know Best
By Fred A. Baughman Jr., MD,
An Albany, NY, couple who faced child abuse charges for taking their son off of Ritalin has been ordered by the court to continue medicating him (A.P., July 19, 2000). Social Service charges against Jill and Michael Carroll were dropped on the condition that they keep 7-year-old Kyle on Ritalin. Social Service workers will be required to visit the family throughout the next year. Does this sound the US? Is it rare?
This is going on in family/divorce courts all over the country, with school-diagnosed, school-coerced, ADHD/Ritalin being the pivotal, divisive issue. In virtually all cases the court sides with the parent believing in ADHD as a 'disease,' and in Ritalin as proven, essential, medical treatment. The parent resisting is deemed negligent and loses their share of custody.
Having participated in 15-20 such cases, I can attest that judges almost always rule along the lines of reigning psychiatry mythology the matter. Hopefully, the science of the matter-that ADHD is not a proven disease, and that the children are NORMAL, will be aired in the near future. ]
Child psychiatrist, Peter S. Jensen, (Opposing View, 8/15/2000 USA Today, p. 16 A) advocates the legal enforcement of drug treatment for ADHD and other psychiatric problems diagnosed in school. He asks:
"So what should society do if a child with a disorder with lifelong consequences (which the panel concluded was true of ADHD) is denied treatment? The answer, of course, depends on the severity of the child's condition, what other treatments have been tried and the likelihood that treatments such as Ritalin will restore that child to normal or near-normal functioning.
Allow us to analyze Jensen's language carefully. By 'disorder' psychiatrists mean 'disease.' Non-psychiatric physicians, on the other hand, would point out that 'disease' means that a physical or a chemical abnormality can be found within the brain or body. This is not true of ADHD and Jensen knows it. Writing "treatments such as Ritalin will restore that child to normal or near-normal functioning, Jensen leaves no doubt he views children with ADHD as "abnormal," which is to say: "diseased."
The 'panel' Jensen invokes, is the panel of the National Institutes of Health, Consensus Conference on ADHD, of November 16-18, 1998. Having heard 3 days of testimony, the panel did not conclude that ADHD was a disabling, crippling, or life-threatening disease--they concluded it was not a disease at all!
ADHD Consensus Conference Panel, November 18, 1998:
".we do not have an independent, valid test for ADHD, and there are no data to indicate that ADHD is due to a brain malfunction."
ADHD, for which we drug 6 million schoolchildren today, remains nothing but an illusion of a disease. Jensen, having gone to medical school, knows this-- knows the difference between normalcy and disease, knows that no abnormality equals no disease!
In an interview in the January, 2000, Readers Digest, F.X. Castellanos summarized a quarter of a century of 'biological' research on ADHD:
"Incontrovertible evidence is still lacking.In time I'm confident we'll confirm the case for organic causes."
Jensen continues (FB: read carefully):
"Not all children (FB: with ADHD or any psychiatric diagnosis--none of them diseases) respond to medication and some benefit from behavioral therapy. Yet society requires that children's caretakers see that children get immunized, schooled, fed and clothed and receive treatments for other disorders such as asthma and diabetes."
About the only time authorities and the courts intervene in parental decision-making, is in the event of a medical emergency in which treatment that is truly life-saving is not being provided. Such might be the case with trauma or an operation with blood loss requiring a transfusion, or in the case of immunization in the face of a grave epidemic, such as that of an outbreak of poliomyelitis or meningococcal meningitis. These might be legitimate reasons to intervene. The examples Jensen gives are asthma, which can present as life-threatening 'status asthmaticus' or 'brittle' diabetes with the blood sugar level fluctuating wildly. I have no argument with Jensen's use of these as examples of life-threatening medical emergencies. Where Jensen must be stopped is in his clear and repeated inferences that ADHD and all emotional and behavioral, psychiatric conditions/diagnoses are akin to medical emergencies, needing and deserving the wresting of parental authority by schools, child protective services, courts and even the legislature-when, not only are they not medical emergencies, grave, life-threatening or crippling-they are not diseases at all!
Far from communicating "what the science says" (Jensen). psychiatry routinely perverts science and medicine, claiming that all problems emotional and behavioral are "brain diseases" due "chemical imbalances of the brain." Accepting this, we accept the need for 'diagnosis,' which, absent disease, is labeling - stigmatizing. Accepting this, we accept the need for 'treatment,' which, absent disease, is drugging - poisoning.
Follow the money.
Enter your email to subscribe to daily Education News!
- Education Technology
- Online Education
- California Education
- Charter Schools
- Teachers Unions
- Education Research
- New York Education
- School Choice
- Education Funding
- STEM Education
- UK Education
- Parent Involvement
- Common Core
- Cost of College
- New York City Schools
- Florida Education
- Julia Steiny
- Texas Education
- School Health
- Math Education
- Los Angeles Schools
- Pennsylvania Education
- Louisiana Education
- Education Reform
- Obama Administration
- New Jersey Education
- Chicago Schools
- College Admissions
- Online Courses
- Teacher Training
- Tennessee Education
- Health Education
- Early Childhood Education
- Ohio Education
- Massachusetts Education
- C. M. Rubin
- Illinois Education
- UK Higher Education
- School Nutrition
- Arne Duncan
- iPads in the Classroom
Plan your career as an educator using our free online datacase of useful information.
- Select a City Subject
- Special Education Schools in Aurora
- Special Education Schools in Canton
- Special Education Schools in Carbondale
- Special Education Schools in Champaign
- Special Education Schools in Charleston
- Special Education Schools in Chicago
- Special Education Schools in Dekalb
- Special Education Schools in Edwardsville
- Special Education Schools in Elmhurst
- Special Education Schools in Evanston
- Special Education Schools in Greenville
- Special Education Schools in Ina
- Special Education Schools in Jacksonville
- Special Education Schools in Joliet
- Special Education Schools in Lisle
- Special Education Schools in Macomb
- Special Education Schools in Normal
- Special Education Schools in Palos Heights
- Special Education Schools in Peoria
- Special Education Schools in Quincy
- Special Education Schools in River Forest
- Special Education Schools in Rockford
- Special Education Schools in Romeoville
- Special Education Schools in Skokie
- Theology Schools in Columbia
- Theology Schools in Louisville
- Theology Schools in Pineville
- Theology Schools in Williamsburg
- Theology Schools in Wilmore